Gothenburg · Tuesday, November 10
Jan Bosch

Jan Bosch

Accelerating the adoption of digital — software, data and AI — technologies in industry and society.
reflection

Daily Reflection #333: Disagree and commit

One of the most underrated skills in organisational life is the ability to argue hard for a position, lose, and then back the chosen path completely. It sounds straightforward. In practice it is rare enough that I notice it when I see it, and the absence does more quiet damage than almost any other behaviour I can think of.

Consider the alternative, which is extremely common. The decision goes the other way, the objector accepts it verbally, and then executes at something like eighty percent. And then, when the approach struggles, as a half-supported approach reliably does, the objection is quietly vindicated. I said so at the time. This is the most corrosive move available in a team, because the evidence it produces is manufactured, and nobody involved, including the objector, is usually aware that it was.

The reason the discipline matters is that most decisions are made under genuine uncertainty, where the chosen path is not obviously right and will only work if people make it work. So the deal is: argue as hard as you can before the decision, with everything you have, and the moment it is made, your private view stops being relevant. If you cannot do that, the honest move is to say so explicitly rather than to withhold quietly. So, as a reflection for today: what are you currently executing at eighty percent because you lost the argument about it?

RADICAL — Five Bullet Friday

Five sharp ideas, every Friday. The essays and the newsletter — not the daily reflections.

Join readers · weekly · unsubscribe anytime
© 2026 Jan Bosch · Boschonian AB · Gothenburg